“IT MAY TAKE A LIFETIME TO BECOME A SPECIALIST IN A CERTAIN FIELD"

“When I graduated in 1993, I felt that the value of my esteemed Delft M.Sc. degree was compromised because the Dutch “Ir." curriculum that took me close to six years to complete what was only four years on paper at that time. Since I aspired to an international career I decided to obtain a North American Master's degree as well. Thus, I pursued my studies in hydrometallurgy at UBC in Vancouver, Canada and also hold an M.A.Sc. degree. Not having a PhD has never been an obstacle in reaching my goals as a water professional working in the industry, whether in plant support, R&D or other roles. So far, it has also not limited me in my interactions with universities, e.g. with giving of guest lectures on industrial water treatment in Delft."

“Boelo puts forth a number of interesting points and I support several. I would, however, like to object to the common inflation of the qualification “specialist". In my opinion, it may take a lifetime to become a specialist in a certain field. In my view, a PhD graduate has deepened his or her understanding of a selected topic but by no means can be considered a specialist (yet). To me, the term specialist comprises elements of practical experience, know-how in addition to knowledge, and people skills. I agree with Boelo that a PhD degree represents a very good academic level, and perseverance as an important character trait of its holder. And this applies internationally and not specifically to the Dutch PhD system. Although I strongly believe that everybody's career path is open I do observe the expected concentration of PhDs in R&D departments in the industry."

“Lastly, I would like to point out that although obviously far more senior managerial and technical jobs are available in the industry than at universities, even with a large global company like YARA, in the end there is only one Plant Manager per production unit or one Principal Engineer in certain key areas of expertise…"